investigation-notes

Investigation Notes

Overview

During bug investigations, maintain a lightweight scratch document as external memory. This prevents re-reading code you've already analyzed, losing track of which hypothesis you're testing, and silently drifting into rabbit holes.

Core principle: Write it down once, refer to it later. Re-reading your one-line note is faster than re-reading 200 lines of source.

Always keep the document up to date with your current focus, hypotheses, and learnings from code reads and tests.

Always refer to the document before re-reading code or forming a new hypothesis. If the information is there, use it. If it's not sufficient, read the code, then write a better note.

The document never takes priority over writing or running a test. If you're choosing between updating notes and writing a test, write the test. Update the notes after.

The Document

Create ~/tmp/investigate-<short-name>.md during orientation (step 2 of /investigate).

The short name should be descriptive enough to identify the investigation (e.g., investigate-concurrent-write.md, investigate-pipe-zombie-state.md).

Once created, notify the user and provide the file path so they can open it in their editor.

Format

# Investigation: <one-line bug description>
 
## Error
 
<assertion/crash message, file:line — written once, never changes>
 
## Current Focus
 
<single sentence: what you are doing RIGHT NOW>
 
## Hypotheses
 
1. [TESTING] <one sentence> — test: <test name or "not yet written">

Creation

Create the document when:

• You have more than one hypothesis to track
• You've read more than 3 files/functions
• You're about to re-read code you already read
• The investigation is going to span multiple iterations of test-write-run

When created, populate Error, Current Focus, your current hypotheses, and anything you've already learned (backfill "Code Read" and "Tests" from what you've done so far).

Rules

• Always update "Current Focus" before starting any new thread of work
• Always Add a hypothesis for what you're doing
• Always update the document after each significant action:
  • After reading a function or file section → add to "Code Read"
  • After forming or rejecting a hypothesis → update "Hypotheses"
  • After running a test → update BEFORE doing anything else. Record: what test ran, what the result was, what it means for the active hypothesis. This is non-negotiable — it takes 30 seconds and prevents the pattern of running multiple tests, losing track of what they proved, and falling back to code reading.
  • After starting a new thread of work → update "Current Focus"
• Do not dump large amounts of code into the document. Instead, reference it by file:line.
• Do not reorganize or reformat the document - this is a scratchpad, not a report.
• You may include brief, simple diagrams if they help you understand and retain information.

Hypothesis Limits

• Maximum 3 active hypotheses at a time. If you want to add a fourth, reject or merge one first.
• Maximum 1 [TESTING] at a time. Commit to one, test it, resolve it, then move on.
• Every hypothesis must have a test or a concrete plan to write one. "Need to investigate further" is not a valid state — that's analysis paralysis wearing a label.

Valid statuses:

• [UNTESTED] — formed but not yet tested. Must become [TESTING] or [REJECTED] soon.
• [TESTING] — actively being tested. Only one at a time.
• [CONFIRMED] — test reproduced the bug as predicted.
• [REJECTED] — test disproved it, or evidence rules it out. Include why.
• [SUPERSEDED] — replaced by a more specific hypothesis. Reference the replacement.